Did She Cheat?

No. Studies show trans women do not have an advantage in sports.

The Research

2024 IOC-Funded Study: Strength, Power and Aerobic Capacity

British Journal of Sports Medicine

An IOC-commissioned study comparing transgender and cisgender athletes found:

Read the full study →

2024: Gender-Affirming Hormone Therapy & Physical Performance

Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism | Co-authored by Kirsti Miller (Australian Olympian)

This peer-reviewed study examined how feminizing hormone therapy affects athletic performance:

Read the full study →

2021 Systematic Review: Sport and Transgender People

Journal of Athletic Training & NIH/PMC

A comprehensive systematic review of transgender athlete research found:

Read the full review →

Expert Perspective: Kirsti Miller (Australian Olympian)

Kirsti Miller is an Australian Olympian, trans athlete, and researcher who co-authored peer-reviewed studies on transgender athletes. She has dedicated her work to debunking myths about trans athletes in sports.

On Olympic Participation Reality:

"Since the IOC has created a rule for trans athletes to compete in 2003, over 71,000 people have become Olympians. Out of those 71,000 Olympians a total of 2 have been trans women & one came dead last the other came 37th out of 42."

— Kirsti Miller

On Trans Athletes Being Under-Represented:

"Many politicians & the TERFS circulate myths about trans women that are transphobic, harmful, & violent. For example, that trans women will overwhelm women's sport, when trans women are in fact under-represented in sport and especially elite sport."

— Kirsti Miller

On The "Divide and Conquer" Tactic:

"Many who oppose the inclusion of trans athletes erroneously claim that allowing trans athletes to compete will harm cisgender women. This divide and conquer tactic gets it exactly wrong."

— Kirsti Miller

On Female Athlete Support:

"A study has confirmed what we all already knew – that the majority of female athletes have absolutely no problem with trans women competing in women's sports."

— Kirsti Miller

On Individual Assessment vs. Blanket Bans:

"Assessing any group of athletes as a monolithic group especially amongst trans athletes is flawed. The sex, gender or chromosomal status of an athlete does not create any inherent danger or risk to safety. Rather, it is disparities in strength, speed & endurance and/or physique of each individual athlete that may, depending on the sport."

— Kirsti Miller

Additional Expert Analysis & Debunking

About This Site

This site exists to counter misinformation spread by SheWon.org and HeCheated.org, which use dubiously-sourced claims and inflated statistics to suggest trans women have competitive advantages—despite peer-reviewed evidence showing the opposite.

These sites:

When you search for information about trans athletes in sports, you deserve accurate, evidence-based answers grounded in peer-reviewed research—not anonymous misinformation. This site provides them.

Debunking SheWon.org & HeCheated.org

The "Displaced Medals" Claim

SheWon claims hundreds or thousands of female athletes have been "displaced" or had "medals stolen" by trans women.

The Problem: This methodology is fundamentally dishonest. A trans woman winning a medal doesn't automatically mean a specific cisgender woman "lost" it. These sites count any medal won by a trans athlete as a "displacement," artificially inflating numbers without scientific or logical basis. Even the Supreme Court noted this "calculation algorithm artificially inflates the number of medals 'lost.'"

Anonymous Sourcing & Extremist Connections

SheWon and HeCheated operate with anonymity while being documented to have connections to extremist communities and organizations designated as hate groups by the Southern Poverty Law Center.

The Problem: Credible research is transparent about who operates it and where data comes from. Anonymous operations making inflammatory claims while connected to extremist networks are red flags for misinformation. Compare this to Kirsti Miller's open, identified work as a published researcher and Olympian.

Ignoring Actual Female Athlete Issues

These sites focus narrowly on trans athletes while largely ignoring systemic issues affecting all female athletes:

  • Pay equity gaps — Women athletes earn significantly less than men
  • Media coverage disparities — Women's sports receive minimal broadcast time
  • Sponsorship and advertising inequity — Less corporate investment in women's sports
  • Sexual assault and harassment accountability — Widespread institutional problems ignored

The Problem: If these organizations genuinely cared about female athletes' welfare, they would prioritize systemic issues affecting millions. Their narrow focus suggests a political agenda rather than genuine advocacy.

Contradicted by Peer-Reviewed Research

The major research findings above directly contradict SheWon's core narrative:

  • 2024 IOC-funded study: Trans women performed worse than cisgender women in key metrics
  • 2024 Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism: No significant performance difference after hormone therapy
  • 2021 Systematic Review: "No direct and consistent research" supports athletic advantage claims
  • Olympic data: Only 2 trans women out of 71,000 Olympic athletes since 2003—one finished dead last

The Problem: When your core argument is contradicted by peer-reviewed, IOC-funded research, your credibility is fundamentally compromised. Yet SheWon continues spreading these claims uncritically.

Female Athletes Support Trans Inclusion

SheWon claims to represent female athletes, but research shows otherwise.

The Problem: Studies confirm that the majority of female athletes have no problem with trans women competing in women's sports. The "protection" narrative manufactured by SheWon doesn't reflect what actual female athletes think or want. This is the same "divide and conquer" tactic used to justify bathroom bans and other discriminatory policies.